Your Accounting, Bookkeeping, Tax, Auditing, Finance and Internal Auditing, CFO and Payroll Solution Provider

Pricing Accounting: Accounting and Bookkeeping Software Online vs. Desktop

Accounting and bookkeeping are the backbone of any business’s financial health, ensuring that transactions are recorded, financial statements are prepared, and taxes are filed on time. Over the years, businesses have transitioned from traditional manual accounting methods to automated software solutions. With the advancement of technology, accounting software has evolved into two main types: online (cloud-based) and desktop-based software. Each type comes with its own set of advantages, disadvantages, costs, and suitability for different businesses. This article explores the pricing of online versus desktop accounting software, considering their advantages and disadvantages, suitability for various business sizes, costs, ongoing fees, training, after-installation support, and which countries they are most suitable for.

1. Overview of Accounting and Bookkeeping Software

Accounting software automates financial transactions and record-keeping tasks. It helps businesses manage their accounting processes, including invoicing, payroll, financial reporting, and tax filing. There are two main types of accounting software:

• Online (Cloud-Based) Accounting Software: This software is hosted on the cloud, meaning users can access their accounting data via the internet from any device. Popular cloud-based accounting software includes QuickBooks Online, Xero, and FreshBooks. These platforms are subscription-based, often with tiered pricing plans depending on features and business needs.

• Desktop Accounting Software: This software is installed and run locally on a computer, where the business’s data is stored directly on the device or a local server. Examples of desktop accounting software include QuickBooks Desktop, Sage 50, and MYOB. These solutions often require a one-time purchase, with optional maintenance and support fees for ongoing updates.

2. Advantages and Disadvantages of Online vs. Desktop Accounting Software

Online Accounting Software

Advantages:

• Accessibility: Cloud accounting software can be accessed from anywhere with an internet connection. This flexibility is ideal for business owners, accountants, and employees who work remotely or have multiple locations.
• Real-Time Updates: Transactions are automatically synced across devices, meaning all users can view the most up-to-date financial data in real-time.
• Automatic Backups: Cloud solutions automatically back up your data, providing a safety net in case of hardware failure or unforeseen issues.
• Scalability: Online accounting software often offers tiered pricing plans that allow businesses to easily scale up as their operations grow. It’s easy to add more users, features, and integrations as needed.
• Collaboration: Multiple users can collaborate on financial data simultaneously, which is ideal for businesses with several departments or teams working on finances. Accountants, bookkeepers, and managers can access the data at the same time without versioning issues.

Disadvantages:

• Dependence on Internet Access: Online software requires a stable internet connection, which may be a limitation in regions with unreliable or slow internet access.
• Security Concerns: Although cloud providers typically implement robust security measures, some businesses, especially those in industries with stringent data privacy laws (such as finance or healthcare), may be hesitant to store sensitive data online.
• Ongoing Subscription Costs: Unlike desktop software, which often requires a one-time fee, cloud accounting software operates on a subscription model, meaning businesses will need to budget for ongoing monthly or annual fees.

Desktop Accounting Software

Advantages:

• Offline Accessibility: Desktop software does not require an internet connection to function, which is beneficial in areas with unreliable or no internet access. Once installed, users can continue to use the software offline.
• One-Time Payment: Many desktop accounting software options are available for a one-time license fee, eliminating the need for monthly or annual subscription payments.
• Greater Control Over Data: With desktop software, businesses can store their data locally on their own servers or devices, which some businesses may prefer for privacy and security reasons.
• Advanced Features: Desktop accounting software often comes with more advanced features for larger businesses, including detailed financial reporting, inventory management, and customized workflows.

Disadvantages:

• Limited Accessibility: Since desktop accounting software is installed on a single device, it cannot be accessed remotely unless set up on a remote server or virtual private network (VPN).
• Manual Backups: Users must perform manual backups, which increases the risk of data loss if backups are not done regularly.
• Maintenance and Updates: Desktop software requires manual updates, which can be time-consuming and require additional technical support.
• Lack of Scalability: As businesses grow, they may find it challenging to scale desktop software due to limitations in features, users, and integrations.

3. Suitability for Business Sizes

Small Businesses

For small businesses with limited budgets and a need for simple, cost-effective accounting solutions, online accounting software is often a more suitable option. Online software like QuickBooks Online and FreshBooks offer affordable entry-level plans that are scalable as the business grows. These platforms often provide core accounting functions such as invoicing, expense tracking, and tax filing without overwhelming small businesses with complex features they may not need.

Online software is ideal for small businesses because:

• It offers lower upfront costs with flexible monthly payments.
• It doesn’t require significant IT infrastructure, making it easier to implement.
• It provides real-time updates, which is useful for businesses that may not have dedicated accountants on staff but need to stay on top of their financials.

Small businesses in remote or rural locations with limited access to internet infrastructure may prefer desktop software for its offline capability. Software such as QuickBooks Desktop or Sage 50 allows businesses to manage their finances without needing an internet connection.

Medium-Sized Businesses

Medium-sized businesses, especially those with several employees or departments, often find themselves balancing between the flexibility of online accounting software and the need for more advanced features offered by desktop solutions. Xero and QuickBooks Online are excellent choices for businesses that are expanding and need more comprehensive functionality, including multi-user access and better reporting.

At this stage, businesses may also be looking for software that can integrate with other business tools such as payroll or customer relationship management (CRM) software. Online software shines here, providing integrations and apps that help businesses automate tasks and stay organized.

For businesses that prefer keeping sensitive data on local servers or have unique regulatory requirements, desktop software may be a better option. Programs like Sage 50 or QuickBooks Desktop provide more control over data security and may offer features that are specifically suited to certain industries or regions.

Large Enterprises

Large enterprises with more complex financial requirements often need enterprise-level solutions. These solutions must handle multi-currency transactions, advanced financial reporting, compliance with international tax regulations, and integration with other business software.

Online accounting solutions like Oracle NetSuite or Microsoft Dynamics 365 are better suited for large businesses because they offer scalable and customizable features designed to handle complex accounting needs. They allow for real-time data access across multiple locations, making them perfect for global operations.

Desktop solutions may not always be the best fit for large businesses due to the lack of scalability, but they are sometimes preferred in certain regions or industries where data privacy regulations make cloud-based solutions less viable.

4. Cost of Online vs. Desktop Accounting Software

The cost of accounting software can vary depending on whether it’s cloud-based (online) or desktop-based, the features it offers, and the number of users.

Online Accounting Software Pricing:

• Basic Plans: Cloud accounting solutions for small businesses generally cost between $10 to $50 per month. These basic plans typically include invoicing, expense tracking, and reporting features.

• Mid-Tier Plans: For growing businesses, mid-tier plans range from $50 to $150 per month. These plans often include more users, integrations, and additional features like payroll, inventory management, and tax filing.

• Enterprise-Level Plans: Large organizations or those with more complex needs can expect to pay $500 to several thousand dollars per month for cloud accounting solutions that cater to large-scale operations. These plans offer advanced features, customizations, and multi-currency management.

Desktop Accounting Software Pricing:

• Basic Plans: Desktop solutions typically have a one-time license fee ranging from $200 to $400 for small businesses. This often includes basic accounting features such as invoicing, expense tracking, and reporting.

• Advanced Plans: For more complex needs, businesses may pay between $500 to $1,500 for more advanced desktop software. This may include inventory management, payroll, and integration with other business systems.

• Enterprise-Level Solutions: Large enterprises may purchase desktop software for $1,000 to $5,000, depending on the number of licenses and the level of functionality required. Additional fees for support and updates are typically charged separately.

5. Annual Maintenance Fees and One-Time Fees

• Online Software: Online accounting software generally does not have one-time fees but requires monthly or annual subscription payments. Some providers offer discounts for annual payments.

• Desktop Software: Desktop accounting software usually involves a one-time payment for the license. However, businesses must often pay annual maintenance and support fees for software updates and technical assistance. These fees can range from $100 to $500 per year.

6. Training and After-Installation Support

Online Software:

• Training: Most online accounting software providers offer comprehensive training resources, including video tutorials, webinars, and online documentation. This training is typically included in the subscription cost.

• Support: Cloud-based accounting software providers usually offer support through live chat, phone, or email. Premium support options may come at an additional cost.

Desktop Software:

• Training: Desktop software vendors often offer training materials, including manuals, online resources, and sometimes in-person training sessions. Training fees may be charged separately.

• Support: Desktop software providers offer support through phone, email, and online chat. However, ongoing support may require an annual maintenance contract.

7. Suitability for Different Countries

The suitability of online or desktop accounting software can vary by region. Cloud-based accounting solutions are more popular in developed countries with high internet access, such as the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia. These countries often have cloud service providers offering region-specific tax features, currencies, and regulations.

In countries with lower internet penetration, or regions where businesses prefer local data storage due to security concerns, desktop software may still be the preferred option. Countries like India, Brazil, and some African nations may have a more significant portion of businesses relying on desktop solutions.

8. Conclusion

Choosing between online and desktop accounting software depends on a business’s size, budget, and specific needs. Online software offers flexibility, scalability, and real-time access, making it ideal for small and medium-sized businesses, especially those with a mobile workforce. Desktop software, on the other hand, offers more control over data and lower long-term costs but lacks the accessibility and scalability of cloud solutions.

Ultimately, businesses need to evaluate their operational requirements, budget, and growth trajectory when selecting the right software solution. Both options offer advantages and drawbacks, and the decision should be made based on the business’s unique circumstances and goals.